Quaker discernment around technology

“The Quaker practice of corporate discernment can provide a crucial moderating force within the frequently polarized public debates about technology. On one side, champions of ‘accelerationism’ celebrate the benefits of technological advancement, emphasizing speed and innovation without sufficient regard for potential social or ethical consequences. On the other side, staunch opposition to technological change can highlight legitimate concern over displacement, dehumanization, or environmental harm, even as these arguments primarily serve to legitimize a diffuse and unexamined fear of change. 

Quaker discernment, with its deep roots in ethical evaluation and community consultation, can act as a fulcrum to balance such extremes. It encourages a thoughtful approach that weighs the benefits of innovation against potential risks, while seeking a path that aligns with the values of integrity, community, and sustainability.

This balanced approach allows Quakers to engage constructively with technology. Rather than blanket acceptance or opposition, Quaker discernment allows its adherents to actively participate in the shaping of new technologies.”

— Brylie Oxley, 2024
Webmaster for Western Friend

What do you do differently during meeting for worship on Zoom compared to worshiping in person? What do you like about it?

If I'm doing it right there is nothing that I do differently. I agree that worship involves our whole being, and we can bring our whole being to worship wherever and however that happens. 

My experience is that if I bring my whole being and my whole attention and focus to a meeting for worship, and I am with others who are doing the same, I can experience a gathered meeting.

For me, the movement of the spirit between people is not constrained by distance. When we sit together and uphold a Friend who is unwell, or one who is undertaking a witness elsewhere, we do so with a hope that we are in some way present with them: that the spirit that is among us is also with them.

Catherine B., Durham, UK
For me, online worship is a place to connect deeply with spirit, just as much as sitting together physically. It is different because you can't smile at a toddler who is quietly playing with their blanket, you can't move to comfort someone who is in distress, and you can't hug your friends at the end of worship. However, during the lonely times of the pandemic, it was a life-line for me as I lived alone. 

I am grateful that folks who are unable to physically attend in person can now have the gift of worship. It is different because you can see folks drinking tea and petting their furballs, but it is still worship. Any opportunity to deepen connection with that which is holy is good.

Linda G., Charlottesville, VA, USA
Worshiping on Zoom means I can be physically comfortable and I can worship more often than possible at my local meeting house. Its lovely to see familiar faces pop up day after day, knowing they're there for the same reason I am. 

Jo M., Northampton, UK
I don’t love Zoom meetings (they feel too much like work) and it’s hard to stay centered but I do like being able to leave a MFW to go to the bathroom without needing to tiptoe out of a silent room of Friends. It’s also a privilege to be able to turn the sound off when a Friend is giving a particularly unseasoned message and I’m busy wondering uncharitably about whether the Spirit really led them to make it. Turning down the sound on my computer allows me to go back to holding them in the Light instead of feeling judgy.

Elizabeth A., Northampton, MA, USA
I've never had the opportunity to attend a Quaker meeting in person. My entire experience of Quakerism has been through Zoom meetings. I realize it may it may be different in some ways, but I have still found a deep sense of connection and spiritual nourishment.

During worship, I often find myself simply sitting in silence, sometimes closing my eyes, sometimes opening them, always trying to listen more deeply and explore the Inner Light within. What I appreciate most is that Zoom has made it possible for me to connect with Friends from different countries and backgrounds, despite the distance.

For me, the Spirit is not limited by geography. I live in eastern DR Congo and I regularly attend Meetings for Worship with Friends in France and the United States, which has allowed me to discover a truly global Quaker family, and that journey continues to enrich my life.

Olo B., South Kivu Province, DR Congo
Mon Jun 15

Our bodies respond to the presence of God

“Quaker worship is not exclusively an activity of the rational, disembodied mind (albeit it is easy to receive this impression in some meetings). Our physical presence is not irrelevant to our participation in communal worship. Worship is the response of our whole being to the presence of God – a response which involves our bodies and the physical presence of our fellow worshippers at least as much as our words and thoughts.” …
Tue Jun 16

Connecting through or despite technology

“We can connect to God and other people regardless of how close we are or how much technology is between us. When we’re ready to connect with the Holy Spirit and… we enter into worship, knowing other people are worshiping at the same time matters.” …
Wed Jun 17

The intimacy of Zoom

“Over Zoom, there is a new intimacy to the gatherings. Faces and expressions are on full display. ‘I really see that they are deep in worship,’ Joan Malin said of her fellow Brooklyn Friends. ‘There’s a vulnerability when someone is doing that, and here they are putting it onscreen for us to witness,’ she said. ‘It helps me get there, too.'” …
Thu Jun 18

Early Quakers were always moving forward

“We should face up to the fact that some of our old ways worked well for some people, but did not work well for others. Zoom has opened some new ways to include people, and enable more variety in how we do things. And we absolutely need to make sure we find ways that include people who don’t find Zoom works for them, too – there’s a balance.” …
Fri Jun 19

Physicality is part of wholeness

“For me, being a ‘whole person’ includes physical embodiment, emotional engagement and intimate relationships with family and friends, and in the physical place where I am. I therefore by definition cannot be a ‘whole person’ in social media. You only see a small (and to me relatively unimportant) part of the wholeness of body, place and relationships that is me. And in particular you only see the intellectual, rational, language-limited part of me…” …
Sat Jun 20

Is it possible to have gathered worship online?

“For me, being a ‘whole person’ includes physical embodiment, emotional engagement and intimate relationships with family and friends, and in the physical place where I am. I therefore by definition cannot be a ‘whole person’ in social media. You only see a small (and to me relatively unimportant) part of the wholeness of body, place and relationships that is me. And in particular you only see the intellectual, rational, language-limited part of me…” …

Read the source of today’s quote

Author

  • Brylie Oxley is a data platform architect and member of Tampere Friends in Finland. He is the webmaster for Western Friend.

    View all posts